ENHANCED CONTROLS:
Users of the Internet in China’s Henan Province face five times more blocked Web sites than the average user, researchers have found
China’s authorities appear to have implemented an enhanced version of the country’s Internet censorship regime in the central Chinese province of Henan, subjecting tens of millions of residents to even stricter controls on access to information than people in the rest of the country.
A research paper titled A Wall Behind A Wall: Emerging Regional Censorship in China published this month by Great Firewall Report, an Internet censorship monitoring platform, found that Internet users in Henan, one of China’s most populous provinces, were on average denied access to five times more Web sites than a typical Chinese Internet user between November 2023 and March.
“Our work documents an alarming sign of regional censorship emerging in China,” said the researchers, who include authors from the University of Massachusetts Amherst and Stanford University.
Photo: EPA-EFE
GREAT FIREWALL
China has the world’s most sophisticated and extensive Internet censorship regime. Internet users cannot access most Western news Web sites or social media platforms, including services provided by Google, Wikipedia and Meta.
Within what has been dubbed the “great firewall,” online content is monitored and censored by a mixture of government authorities and private companies complying with laws that require them to delete any content considered “sensitive.” That includes any information about historical or current events that goes against the Chinese Communist Party’s official narrative.
The researchers began looking into the topic after Internet users in Henan reported that Web sites accessible in other parts of China were inaccessible in their province. They found that millions of domains that were not blocked by China’s centralized firewall were at some point inaccessible in Henan.
By buying servers from Internet cloud providers, the authors tested the flow of Internet traffic from locations within Henan. They tested the Internet’s top 1 million domains daily between November 2023 and March, with a gap of several months last year.
The results showed that the Henan firewall blocked nearly 4.2 million domains at some point during the research period, more than five times more than the about 741,500 domains blocked by China’s national firewall.
The domains that were specifically blocked in Henan were mainly from business-related Web sites.
There have been several finance-related protests in Henan in recent years, which the researchers said could be the reason for the additional controls on access to information about the economy being controlled.
PROTESTS
In 2022, thousands of people in Henan took part in several demonstrations after they were blocked from withdrawing cash from their bank accounts. The crisis escalated when protesters reported that their mobile health codes, part of the pandemic control measures in place at the time, had turned red, preventing them from travelling or entering buildings. Five officials were later punished for abusing the health code system to quell the protests.
Other parts of China have also been subjected to enhanced Internet controls. In July 2009, following deadly ethnic riots, the Chinese government imposed an Internet blackout in Xinjiang, a region in western China home to the Uyghur minority, that lasted 10 months. Since then, the use of the Internet in Xinjiang has been much more tightly monitored than in the rest of the country. Online activities in Tibet are also strictly controlled.
The emergence of a regional censorship regime in Henan is unusual because it is not a region of China that is normally considered especially restive by the Chinese authorities.
The researchers could not determine if the enhanced controls were imposed by the local authorities in Henan or the central government in Beijing.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Rapid advances in China’s artificial intelligence (AI) companies are a boon to both the censors and those who wish to evade them.
The Chinese Ministry of Public Security (MPS) recently unveiled new surveillance tools that can monitor people who use virtual private networks, software that allows people to circumvent the Internet firewall.
The MPS’ research institute also showcased a tool that it claimed could monitor accounts on Telegram, a messaging app. The tool has already collected more than 30 billion messages, the institute said.
Mingshi Wu, the lead author of the Henan study, who uses a pseudonym to protect their identity, said: “On the one hand, AI could be leveraged to create more sophisticated, adaptive and efficient censorship and surveillance tools. On the other hand, AI also enables new opportunities for those seeking to understand and circumvent censorship. For example, AI can assist in developing more agile testing tools for detecting censorship.”
The Henan Cyberspace Affairs Commission could not be reached for comment.
